Radboud Annals of Medical Students

RAMS

  • Home
  • News
    • Newsletter archive
  • About
    • RAMS
    • The Board
      • The General Board
        • The General Board (2021-2022)
        • Previous General Boards
      • The Editorial Board
        • The Editorial Board (2021-2022)
        • Previous Editorial Boards
    • The Supervisory Board
    • Reviewers and Editors
    • RAMS Committees
      • Symposium Committee
      • Masterclass Committee
  • Editions
    • 2021-2022
      • Twentieth Edition – September 2021
      • Twentyfirst Edition – December 2021
      • Twenty second Edition – March 2022
    • 2020-2021
      • Sixteenth edition – September 2020
      • Seventeenth edition – December 2020
      • Eighteenth edition – March 2021
      • Nineteenth Edition – June 2021
    • 2019-2020
      • Fourteenth edition – December 2019
      • Fifteenth edition – April 2020
      • Sixteenth edition – September 2020
    • 2018-2019
      • Eleventh Edition – September 2018
      • Twelfth Edition – January 2019
      • Thirteenth edition – May 2019
    • 2017 – 2018
      • Ninth Edition – November 2017
      • Tenth Edition – February 2018
    • 2016-2017
      • Sixth Edition – November 2016
      • Seventh Edition – March 2017
      • Eighth Edition – July 2017
    • 2015-2016
      • Third Edition – November 2015
      • Fourth Edition – March 2016
      • Fifth Edition – June 2016
    • 2014-2015
      • Pilot Edition – June 2014
      • First Edition – January 2015
      • Second Edition – June 2015
  • For Authors
    • Submit your Article
    • Research internship
  • For Supervisors
  • For Reviewers
  • Contact
  • Privacy policy
Je bent hier: Home / News / Lifting or running: which gives you that six-pack faster?

Lifting or running: which gives you that six-pack faster?

2 juli 2019 by Rams

Quentin Marsman

The last few years people are increasingly hitting the gym to work on their physique, most importantly to lose fat. Most men start lifting to increase their muscle mass and acquire the beloved six-pack, whereas most women jump on the treadmill to burn calories and ultimately lose fat and weight. The new Dutch guideline for sports and exercise from 2017 advises people to do muscle and bone strengthening exercises next to cardiovascular exercises, like playing football or running on a treadmill [1]. The question then arises which of these two methods of exercise is actually superior when looking at the way it contributes to fat loss.

To compare the number of calories burned between sports, we can use the metabolic equivalent (MET) values. One MET is defined as the energy needed to lie or sit quietly or the consumption of 3.5 mL O2/kg/min [2]. When we compare running with strength training we see that the MET value of running (on a treadmill) is 7.00, while strength training has a mere 3.00, i.e. running burns more calories than lifting [2]. However, strength training has additional benefits for the energy expenditure of the body. This effect is twofold. Firstly, when doing strength training, microtrauma occur in muscles which require energy to repair. According to a study by Westcott, this effect holds on for about 72 hours and increases resting metabolic rate (RMR) during this time from five percent to nine percent [3].

The second effect of strength training is a long term effect, namely the chronic increase in RMR. The same study by Westcott shows an approximate seven percent increase in RMR after several weeks of lifting [3]. The theory behind this suspected increase in RMR is based on the fact that the resting metabolism depends for a great deal on the energy expenditure of muscles, with muscles contributing to around 30% of the total resting metabolism [4]. Increasing muscle mass would lead to more energy spend by muscles and thus increasing the RMR. However, this effect is debatable as some research shows the effect, whereas other studies fail to detect this increase. A study by Lemmer et al. managed to show the increase in RMR in men but failed to show this effect in women [5].

Concluding, cardiovascular training and strength training have two different effects on your body. Where cardiovascular training burns more calories during the exercise, strength training burns more calories in the long term. While both methods serve their own place in losing fat, lifting seems to have a more long term effect via the increased resting metabolism. So, looking at that sixpack, running seems to give it to you faster, but lifting seems to have the edge, due to its long term effect.

 

[1] Gezondheidsraad. Beweegrichtlijnen 2017. (Gezondheidsraad, Den Haag,  2017).
[2] Tudor-Locke, C., et al. Linking the American Time Use Survey (ATUS) and the Compendium of Physical Activities: methods and rationale. Journal of physical activity & health 6, 347-353 (2009).
[3] Westcott, W.L. Resistance Training is Medicine: Effects of Strength Training on Health. Current Sports Medicine Reports 11, 209-216 (2012).
[4] Zurlo, F., et al. Skeletal muscle metabolism is a major determinant of resting energy expenditure. The Journal of Clinical Investigation 86, 1423-1427 (1990).
[5] Lemmer, J.T., et al. Effect of strength training on resting metabolic rate and physical activity: age and gender comparisons. Medicine and science in sports and exercise 33, 532-541 (2001).

Categorie: News, Uncategorized

RAMS Newsletter

RAMS complies to the GDPR. By submitting your e-mail address to us you agree with our Privacy Policy.

Social Media


Sponsors & Partners

  • Brian Gardner
  • Lauren Mancke
  • Nathan Rice
  • Nick Croft
  • Rafal Tomal
  • Ron Rennick
© Copyright 2014 RADBOUD ANNALS OF MEDICAL STUDENTS · All Rights Reserved · Powered by PLatform11
Beheer cookie toestemming

Om de beste ervaringen te bieden, gebruiken wij technologieën zoals cookies om informatie over je apparaat op te slaan en/of te raadplegen. Door in te stemmen met deze technologieën kunnen wij gegevens zoals surfgedrag of unieke ID's op deze site verwerken. Als je geen toestemming geeft of uw toestemming intrekt, kan dit een nadelige invloed hebben op bepaalde functies en mogelijkheden.

Functioneel Altijd actief
De technische opslag of toegang is strikt noodzakelijk voor het legitieme doel het gebruik mogelijk te maken van een specifieke dienst waarom de abonnee of gebruiker uitdrukkelijk heeft gevraagd, of met als enig doel de uitvoering van de transmissie van een communicatie over een elektronisch communicatienetwerk.
Voorkeuren
De technische opslag of toegang is noodzakelijk voor het legitieme doel voorkeuren op te slaan die niet door de abonnee of gebruiker zijn aangevraagd.
Statistieken
De technische opslag of toegang die uitsluitend voor statistische doeleinden wordt gebruikt. De technische opslag of toegang die uitsluitend wordt gebruikt voor anonieme statistische doeleinden. Zonder dagvaarding, vrijwillige naleving door uw Internet Service Provider, of aanvullende gegevens van een derde partij, kan informatie die alleen voor dit doel wordt opgeslagen of opgehaald gewoonlijk niet worden gebruikt om je te identificeren.
Marketing
De technische opslag of toegang is nodig om gebruikersprofielen op te stellen voor het verzenden van reclame, of om de gebruiker op een website of over verschillende websites te volgen voor soortgelijke marketingdoeleinden.
Beheer opties Beheer diensten Beheer leveranciers Lees meer over deze doeleinden
Bekijk voorkeuren
{title} {title} {title}